Facebook launches new market research app after pulling similar app in January

Facebook has rolled out a new Study from Facebook marketing research program that involves users downloading an app to collect data from their phone. The company said the the information it collects will go toward product development initiatives.

“Market research helps companies build better products for people. We believe this work is important to help us improve our products for the people who use Facebook,” wrote Facebook product manager Sagee Ben-Zedeff.

In January, Facebook removed its Research app from the iOS app store after being accused of paying teenagers for access to their mobile activity via a VPN app that gave Facebook nearly unlimited access to user data and phone activity.

How Facebook’s latest research program works. Facebook is promoting the program by running ads asking people to participate. If someone clicks on an ad, they’ll will be asked to register — and if they qualify — will be asked to download the Study with Facebook app from the Google Play Store.

Participants must be 18 years old, and currently it is only available to people in the U.S. and India.

Facebook is compensating users for participating in the market research program, but did not give details on how much money users would earn. (Facebook’s previous research program paid users $20 a month to have the app installed on their phone.)

What information is Facebook collecting? Once the app has been downloaded, it collects and analyzes the following information:

  • The apps a user has installed on their phone.
  • How much time a user spends on each app.
  • App activity names and the app features users are taking advantage of.
  • The user’s country, device and network type.

Facebook said it is not collecting user IDs, passwords or any content like photos, videos or messaging. The company also said it will not sell any information it collects via the app to third parties or use it to target ads. Also, the data collected will not be added to the person’s Facebook account information if they are a Facebook user.

Why we should care. Facebook’s mismanagement of user data has been a thorny issue for marketers. Advertisers have reaped the benefits of the company’s ad targeting capabilities, but marketers want safe platforms — and channels — where their messaging can be heard without the risk of people’s data being misused, or worse, stolen.

Facebook said the information it collects via its Study with Facebook program will not be used for ad targeting, and that the research is going toward building “better products” for its users. As Facebook shifts to become more of a messaging platform focused on privacy, better products will benefit marketers wanting to more ways to engage with their audiences on Facebook’s family of apps (Facebook, Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp).

But, the catch for the research participants — and by extension, marketers — is whether or not Facebook can be trusted and that the information it is collecting will not be mishandled or result in another user privacy crisis.


About The Author

Amy Gesenhues is a senior editor for Third Door Media, covering the latest news and updates for Marketing Land, Search Engine Land and MarTech Today. From 2009 to 2012, she was an award-winning syndicated columnist for a number of daily newspapers from New York to Texas. With more than ten years of marketing management experience, she has contributed to a variety of traditional and online publications, including MarketingProfs, SoftwareCEO, and Sales and Marketing Management Magazine. Read more of Amy’s articles.

How to make online reviews one of your most powerful SEO weapons

How to make online reviews one of your most powerful SEO weapons

Online reviews and SEO have been closely tied together for a long time. That’s common knowledge at this point. According to Moz, online reviews are estimated to make up 10% of the criteria for how Google displays search results.

That’s a hefty chunk!

The importance of online reviews in today’s business world is undeniable. However, thanks to the famously secretive Google algorithms, knowing exactly how to leverage them to achieve stellar rankings is still somewhat of an ambiguous task.

Over the years, there have been all kinds of studies and strategic advice given on how to work customer reviews into SEO plans. While the precise details will vary from company-to-company (and industry-to-industry), there are several commonalities that can be applied across the board.

Let’s talk about a few of the big ones in making online reviews one of the strongest weapons in your SEO arsenal.

Develop a strategy to collect in numbers

First and foremost, online reviews aren’t doing your SEO strategy any good if you aren’t getting them!

Google and other search engines like to see that people are choosing your business and taking the time to leave their opinion on it. Unfortunately, most people won’t take the time to write a review on their own, unless the experience was exceptionally bad. In fact, studies have found that more than 30% of consumers will leave a negative review following a subpar experience!

That being said, you need to make a conscious effort to collect reviews from as many customers as you can. The good news is that 70% of consumers will leave a review if asked – per a BrightLocal study.

Plain and simple, you need a plan to follow up with customers after their experience to gauge their thoughts. Now, this is a task you need to handle carefully.

Step one deals with timeliness

Regardless of whether your review follow-ups are done through email campaigns, SMS messages, review landing pages, or anything else of that nature, the timing needs to be impeccable. Give it a day or two before you send out your request for a review. Generally speaking, it’s typically ideal to send these requests in the mornings for the best response rates.

Step two is the approach

Asking people to leave reviews is a game of happy mediums. On one hand, you want to develop the form to get the most genuine and detailed responses as possible. However, you don’t want to ask questions that are so complex that you turn people away.

Keep it simple. A short form asking for the pros, cons, and overview is nice and short, yet encourages in-depth responses.

Example of a detailed positive review

Source

Always remember, a detailed, honest review is worth way more than a short review with a simple star rating and a quick sentence.

Step three is persistence

If people don’t respond to your review request, you definitely want to give them a nudge. But, you don’t want to overstep. Keep your follow-ups to no more than two, and space them a few days apart.

Quantity of reviews plays a big role in how the search engines rank businesses on the web. That said, you can’t rely on people to review your company on their own. Do yourself a favor and nail down a rock-solid strategy early on!

Know how to respond properly to both good and bad reviews

These days, responding to reviews is just as important as gathering reviews. Many would argue it’s even more important!

To reference the BrightLocal study again, most customers read review responses when looking at a new business.

Statistical graph on how people refer to reviews

Source

Earlier this year, Google actually confirmed that responding to reviews plays a role in SEO.

Here is what Google had to say on the matter:

Responding to reviews shows that you value your customers and the feedback they leave about your business.

This action ideally works to build trust between a business and its customers. So, when you receive a review (whether it be good or bad), you need to have a plan in place to address it properly.

Most importantly, when responding to a review, let it air out. You never, never, never want to respond to a review when you are emotionally charged. For example, let’s say you have a customer from hell who wrote a scathing review, even though they weren’t completely right.

Chances are, you read this review and had a million things you’d like to say to them. However, you need to remember that your responses are public! Regardless of the context behind the review, you need to approach it with a level head. Give it at least a couple hours before you respond. But no more than a couple days.

Here is a great example of how not to respond to a bad review.

Source

When you are responding to negative reviews, there are a few key components to remember. However, you may choose to use these according to what would suit your brand the best.

Address the reviewer by name.

  1. Thank them for taking the time to leave a review.
  2. Try to personalize your response with context from their individual experience.
  3. Look at the review as objectively as possible. Were there any internal shortcomings that caused this review?
  4. Apologize and empathize.
  5. Accept responsibility where it is due.
  6. Take the conversation offline.
  7. Offer actionable solutions.
  8. Once resolved, ask the customer if they would be willing to change their review.

Here is a fantastic example of how to handle a negative review like a champion

Example of effectively handling negative reviews

Source

Not only does the responder do a great job at empathizing with the issue, but they also provide a great deal of actionable information, as well as an avenue to take the conversation offline. This one hits the nail on the head!

In regards to responding to positive reviews, the rules to live by are quite a bit less volatile.

  1. Thank the customer for their review.
  2. Be personal with the response. Don’t come off as cookie cutter.
  3. Encourage them to come back.

Example of responding to positive reviews

Source

Always remember, the way you respond to reviews says WAY more about your business than the review itself. If you’re smart and collected about it, you can potentially turn negative sentiment into brand loyalty, and of course, excellent rankings on Google!

Choose review platforms wisely

There are all kinds of online review platforms out there these days. Some are more general, while others are niche-focused. When you choose which platforms you want to be gathering reviews on, there is a lot that should go into your decision.

In addition to getting registered on the major ones like Google Reviews, Facebook Reviews, Yelp, and the others, you need to take your industry into account. For instance, if you are a SaaS company, gathering reviews on sites like Capterra and G2 Crowd is vastly important. If you are a restaurant, consider sites like Zomato and OpenTable.

In terms of SEO value, it’s important to note that not all review platforms are equal in the eyes of Google. Even though a platform is a verified Google Review Partner, it doesn’t mean that it’s the best of the bunch.

When you are looking at review platforms for SEO, there are a few key factors that should come into play.

  1. How many total reviews are written on this platform every month?
  2. How many businesses are registered on this platform?
  3. Are you able to qualify for Rich Snippet Stars with this platform?
  4. How does this platform work to combat fake reviews?

To give you an idea, here is how SEMrush ranks several review platforms in regards to SEO value:

Chart on review platform rankings

Source

Take your time in doing research here. You need every single review to maximize your potential of ranking on the SERPs.

Let reviews guide your customer experience

When push comes to shove, the common denominator in using reviews to boost SEO value is getting people to leave good, honest feedback.

The best way to do this is to provide an exceptional customer experience (obviously). But, customers and search engine robots also want to see that you are using the customer reviews you get to improve the user experience (UX) for the best.

When people leave reviews, you need to look at the words as objectively as possible. In other words, reviews need to be seen as constructive criticism.

Make it a point to take inventory of your new and existing reviews every month. Try to spot patterns that shed light on bigger issues.

For instance, let’s say you are in the SaaS industry and provide an email marketing program. If you got a bunch of new reviews in the past month and a decent amount of them address a similar issue related to client support, this is a clear-cut sign you need to re-evaluate (and maybe step up) this area of the UX. Perhaps incorporating a live chat or chatbot feature to the website dashboard might be a solution.

The bottom line is that reviews serve the monumental purpose of spotlighting weak areas within a business. If you are able to use them to improve the lives of your customers, you will be rewarded – both in terms of SEO and revenue.

The wrap

Online reviews are an SEO weapon with a massive amount of firepower. The tricky part is truly understanding how to use them properly.

Ultimately, it all comes down to your ability to gather them on the right platform, respond appropriately, and of course, use them to better your company in the big picture. This is all easier said than done. Hopefully, this article has given you a good idea of where to start.

Manish Dudharejia is the President and Founder of E2M Solutions Inc.

Related reading

Image optimization for SEO Everything you need to know for success

A guide to implementing Google’s “How-to” schema

Goodbye to average position on Google SERPs

A look under the hood of profitable e-commerce websites

Steve Jobs put it well when he said, “Simple can be harder than complex…but it’s worth it in the end because once you get there, you can move mountains.”

This mantra has worked for Apple for decades, and it certainly holds true for digital design as well. Particularly when you’re talking about e-commerce websites. Simplicity has been proven to routinely yield higher conversion rates, deliver a more positive experience, and even build trust among visitors. Why? In short, calls to action become more prominent, users aren’t overwhelmed or frustrated, and there are often fewer site issues.

We’re logging more hours online than ever before, so naturally, we crave digital experiences that are intuitive, visually calming and straightforward. But creating simplicity on the frontend doesn’t necessarily mean the backend infrastructure of the website is uncomplicated. Simplicity often requires greater behind-the-scenes complexity.

The devil’s in the details and so is simplicity.

If your website isn’t clear cut and easy to navigate, there’s not enough attention to detail going on behind the scenes. The road to attaining a minimalistic website that delivers a streamlined user experience is paved with important design considerations.

First impressions are just as important on the web

The reality facing any website owner is they have less than 15 seconds to capture the attention of a visitor –– and that’s being generous. Your website’s bounce rate is contingent on how your website looks to the visitor. According to The State of Content report conducted by Adobe, 38% of people [pdf] will stop engaging with a website if the content or layout is unattractive.

Unsurprisingly, 94% of negative website feedback can be attributed to bad design. But the key to successful web design is still all about paying close attention to detail and ensuring your visitors not only have the information they need but that it’s easy and quick to access.

Clutter does not spark joy

Eye-tracking technologies are already highlighting how digital distractions and clutter can dramatically affect the conversion rates of website users. Tobii Pro, a Swedish company that develops and sells products for eye control and eye tracking, turned this challenge into an opportunity by using eye tracking to help KLM Royal Dutch Airlines redesign their online travel ticket system. By tracking overall flow through the buying process and comprehension of the individual steps, they were able to design a ticket-buying tool around behavior and user need that increased conversions by 30%.

Clutter also directly impacts loading times, which is extremely important when it comes to the user experience. In fact, according to the aforementioned Adobe report, 39% of people will stop engaging with a website if the images won’t load or take too long to load. Which seems par for the course when considering 53% of mobile users will leave any web page that takes longer than three seconds to load.

Slow load times are a direct result of having too much on one page and are one of the key indicators of bad decision making and sloppy backend work.

The importance of having a clear call to action

It is no accident that many of the highest-performing e-commerce sites feature a clear call to action. CTAs, if done correctly, can dramatically increase conversion rates. But they must be visible, clear and compelling. Don’t make visitors work for the desired next action.

One quick and simple way to increase site conversion is to put CTAs “above the fold” so that visitors don’t have to scroll down to see it. In fact, one study revealed content placed above the fold was seen by visitors 102% more times than anything placed below it. And when a software company that produces landing pages experimented with this theory and moved its CTA above the fold, conversions spiked 41%.

To realize an even bigger boost from your CTAs, personalize them. When visitors are met with tastefully done personalizations and specific product recommendations, it demonstrates you understand them, which helps build loyalty.

Make it easy for customers to reach out

One of the top complaints most site visitors have is not being able to locate the company’s contact information easily. If you rely on local foot traffic, your name, address and phone (NAP) should be on every page. Nothing will frustrate a visitor more than having to hunt for contact information.

Even if you are an e-commerce seller, drop shipper or wholesaler, it is imperative you have your NAP information strategically placed in plain view – in many cases above the fold to eliminate the need for your buyers to scroll down or jump through virtual hoops to find it. Having a clearly labeled NAP validates your store’s legitimacy and eases the minds of shoppers who always have the option to hunt for a similar product on Amazon, Target or other online retailers if they find your website’s information too confusing.

Empower your customers

It goes without saying that a happy customer will be a returning customer. And to keep them happy, your website should be well-equipped with a variety of self-service tools to help them identify the answers to their questions – and fast. Today’s customers expect a website to have a self-service application and now, many prefer self-service over human contact.

Self-service tools can take the form of on-site calculators, downloadable guides and checklists, and even quizzes. Having these in place can also significantly cut down on inbound customer service requests by proactively answering questions before they become an issue. For instance, we recently worked with a skincare product retailer that operates exclusively online. One challenge they routinely dealt with was customers wanting guidance on which products were best for their skin type. The retailer wanted to empower its customers to get this information instantaneously while also reducing demands on their customer support team. By simply developing a quiz, they helped customers identify the product best-suited for their needs, cut down the number of customer service calls and help build confidence and trust between the company and the customer.

Keep in mind, these tools are only effective if they are simple and straightforward. That requires time spent behind the scenes thinking through the customer’s path, the desired goal or outcome and how it will match your brand’s look, feel and tone.

Complexity always precedes simplicity – and simplicity is what today’s consumer craves. Take a look at your online presence through that lens. Will it move mountains or has it inadvertently become a barrier?


Opinions expressed in this article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Marketing Land. Staff authors are listed here.


About The Author

Sahil is a software developer turned strategist for medtech, martech, e-commerce and nonprofit organizations. With over 10 years of experience working in software development and digital marketing, he leverages his experience and knowledge to build robust digital products, bringing a unique perspective to product development lifecycle and marketing strategies. Sahil leads the team at AKOS Digital, an agile digital agency that believes in outcome-based innovation to design, develop and launch full-scale digital products. Based in Phoenix, Arizona, AKOS holds expertise in web applications, website design and development, SEO, UI/UX, and strategic marketing.

Are revenue optimization teams the answer to alignment issues between sales and marketing?

Challenges between sales and marketing, stemming from broader organizational issues, are not uncommon. From miscommunication to mismatched data, there are plenty of frustrating problems that hinder alignment across siloed teams. A recent report (registration required) from Aragon Research found that customer revenue optimization helps organizations increase sales volume, improve win rates and deal sizes while delivering increased customer value. The research also showed that marketers tend to grade their relationship with sales higher than their counterparts on the sales team — indicative of just how disconnected these teams can be.

Co-founder and executive vice president of enterprise software firm Altify, Áine Denn, recognized these challenges when she co-founded the firm in 2005. “Sales and marketing aren’t speaking the same language,” said Denn. “Buyers have elevated expectations, but many brands’ sales and marketing teams are disconnected.”

Revenue optimization teams can reframe conversations

As businesses increasingly shift toward subscription-based models, brands apply an account-based marketing strategy to support the sales process. According to Altify’s chief marketing officer Patrick Morrisey, it’s time for a fundamental shift in our sales and marketing efforts, and even our larger organizational structures. “We need to shift the conversation from ‘what are we trying to sell’ to ‘what problems are we trying to solve?’”, said Morrisey. “That’s where the revenue optimization team comes in.”  He also noted that by creating a revenue optimization team, brands can increase transparency into sales campaigns and provide better insights into their digital marketing efforts.

“As marketers, our roles are changing as the buying cycle continues to shift,” said Allie Hughes, founder of Hughes & Co., a digital marketing agency with a strategic focus on profitability and revenue generation. “We need a better picture of the sales process to get better at what we do.”

One step towards solving the challenges of accessibility, insights and transparency across teams is to establish deal review meetings with the internal stakeholders involved in an account’s sales process. “It’s not the ‘old-world’, tech-driven center of excellence,” says Morrisey. “It’s establishing cross-functional resources grounded in account plans and driven by processes and metrics bringing internal stakeholders to the table.”

Cross-functional teams can lead to more effective campaigns

By establishing a cross-functional revenue optimization team and involving stakeholders from across sales and marketing in the process from beginning to end, digital marketers can set the tone for the entire sales process. Building rapport with your counterparts in sales — from business development to customer success managers — will provide valuable insights your team can act on to drive conversions. Partnering with the product marketing team and involving them in the process is also critical for ensuring that sales is well-equipped to manage customers’ expectations and solve challenges.

“Buyers can be extremely well-informed. Sales need to be equipped with accurate information from business development, product marketing team to deliver the right message — and solutions — to the customer during the sales process,” said Morrisey. “The tangible value that marketers are delivering to customers is actually equipping the sales team to understand the customer and products that will best solve the customer’s problems.”

Alignment can lead to competitive advantage

The view into accounts that marketing receives from sales generally doesn’t extend much further than the information put in the organizations’ CRM. This makes it challenging for marketers to understand the customer’s expectations and needs. “Sales very inadequately supports marketing with the information and insights that they need to understand how to shift marketing campaigns,” said Denn.

“Marketing is a sales-enabling activity, with more access to information about the entire sales process our efforts are more informed, our data-based decision making has a stronger foundation and ultimately our marketing efforts and products will scale up in quality as these teams are implemented in companies,” said Hughes. “We see clients shifting in this direction and our capacity to help generate strong ROI is improving.”

The importance of alignment cannot be understated; our sales and marketing teams should be as well-informed as the customers we are trying to reach.


About The Author

Jennifer Videtta Cannon serves as Third Door Media’s Senior Editor, covering topics from email marketing and analytics to CRM and project management. With over a decade of organizational digital marketing experience, she has overseen digital marketing operations for NHL franchises and held roles at tech companies including Salesforce, advising enterprise marketers on maximizing their martech capabilities. Jennifer formerly organized the Inbound Marketing Summit and holds a certificate in Digital Marketing Analytics from MIT Sloan School of Management.

Digital transformation fueled Salesforce’s record quarter

The global adoption of digital technologies is transforming how consumers and businesses operate interact drastically. While CXOs continue to embrace — and implement — the concept of digital transformation, technology vendors like global CRM Salesforce continue to dominate the marketplace. Earlier this week, Salesforce announced a record $3.74 million in revenue in its first quarter of its fiscal year 2020, an increase of 24% year-over-year.

The marketing cloud and commerce solutions alone saw 33% growth. Its service cloud surpassed $1 billion in revenue for the quarter for the first time.

“Our strong revenue growth in the quarter reflects the strength of our business and the tremendous demand we’re seeing from customers worldwide,” said Keith Block, co-CEO of Salesforce in prepared remarks. “Companies of every size and industry are undergoing a digital transformation to better serve their customers and they are choosing Salesforce as their partner.”

Why we should care

As leaders shift organizational objectives toward digital transformation, the influx of new workplace technologies comes as no surprise to digital marketing teams. Most of us had to adapt to the ever-evolving martech landscape quickly — and before the rest of our organizations.

Salesforce’s growth this past quarter demonstrates that organizations are, in fact, adapting and embracing the necessary changes. And with CMOs reportedly investing roughly 30 percent of their budgets in martech, it’s clear that the transformation is here. Consumers expecting better customer experiences will continue to drive digital teams to adopt new technologies, increasing our reliance on vendors like Salesforce.

More on Salesforce

  • At last week’s TrailheaDX 2019 Conference, the company revealed Salesforce Blockchain, a low-code blockchain solution that will be natively available to Salesforce users.
  • Salesforce recently launched its new Datorama marketplace,  for brands and agencies to develop customer applications with a focus on marketing intelligence.

About The Author

Jennifer Videtta Cannon serves as Third Door Media’s Senior Editor, covering topics from email marketing and analytics to CRM and project management. With over a decade of organizational digital marketing experience, she has overseen digital marketing operations for NHL franchises and held roles at tech companies including Salesforce, advising enterprise marketers on maximizing their martech capabilities. Jennifer formerly organized the Inbound Marketing Summit and holds a certificate in Digital Marketing Analytics from MIT Sloan School of Management.

Regulation in the SEO industry – Impossible or essential?

Regulation in the SEO industry - Impossible or essential

We all get them, the offers of free SEO audits, of thousands of backlinks from “DA 40 and above” sites for just $10 and the “helpful” list of spurious SEO issues with your website.

Checking your junk folder every morning reveals another round of emails offering the SEO-moon-on-a-stick for a low, low price. As an SEO working for a search marketing agency I used to find receiving these emails misplaced but amusing.

Screenshot of email received listing questionable SEO issues with the Avenue Digital website

Email received listing questionable SEO issues with the Avenue Digital website

I no longer laugh at these emails. These annoyances, although easily ignored through the press of the “delete” key, reveal something more sinister about the SEO industry – really anyone can offer SEO services. What the SEO-literate might discard as part of their daily email purge others will read, digest and panic over. Receiving an email claiming you could be losing hundreds of dollars a day through the poor optimization of your website is enough to make anyone outside of the industry sit-up and take notice. Small businesses appear to be particularly vulnerable, and it’s not just emails that they are subjected to. During my time working as an in-house marketer, I became aware of just how often businesses are pestered over the phone by people claiming to work for Google, who, in reality, wanted to sell links or directory listings. I’ve also seen the regret of local businesses who have taken them up on their offer and then needed to turn to a legitimate SEO to fix their sites after they’ve accrued manual actions or dropped off the SERPs for their core, revenue-driving terms.

The problem, as I see it, is that “legitimate SEO” is a subjective term. Within our industry, there are no definitive criteria someone must meet before they can call themselves an SEO.  Whereas in other professions there are minimum qualifications before one can practice, with search engine optimization the barrier to entry is a laptop and enough knowledge of the lingo to convince a layman of your expertise.  How, then, are prospective clients supposed to determine if the practitioner they are looking to work with, or hire, actually has the ability to do a good job?

My agency, Avenue Digital, has been trying to combat this issue with education.  Our guide on how to find the best SEO agency for your business is the culmination of years of talking to clients about their previous disappointments with agencies and our own experiences of taking over the websites of clients who have suffered at the hands of mavericks. Unfortunately, this is just one step in the right direction. Does there need to be more done to protect vulnerable businesses from the expensive mistake of hiring a poor performing SEO or agency? Does our industry need to be regulated?

This is something I’ve been mulling over for a while, so I threw the question out to SEO Twitter, and was surprised and impressed by the volume of responses.

It appears that many SEOs in the industry are in favor of doing something to bring a quality standard to our work. There were many suggestions; qualifications, ongoing professional development, and governing bodies.

The issue

Unlike medicine which has a set of accepted premises and procedures that each aspiring doctor must train in and be tested on, SEO is highly disputed and one person’s “best practice” is another’s route to failure. In response to my question about regulation Dawn Anderson, MD of Move It Marketing raised a very good point that, “the industry is based largely on educated opinion. We cannot even agree on subdomains versus subfolders.” How then are we to regulate an industry that can’t even agree with what “right” is?

It’s true that as SEOs our methods often differ, but is there a way we can ensure that all people offering it as a service are upholding a minimum standard of quality?

Governing body

An obvious way of regulating the industry would be through the formation of a body that oversees the conduct of registered members. Through membership the SEO would agree to be subject to the governance of the body, adhering to its rules. Members could be recorded on a list that would be available to companies to access in order to check if the agency or contractor they are considering is a member.

This would have its own limitations, however. As previously discussed, agreeing on rules under which the SEOs would operate would be tough. It would be simple to agree on client treatment and standards of reporting for instance, but as there’s no universally agreed upon method of conducting search engine optimization. It would be hard to police the methods and results of these registered practitioners.

External auditing

For a governing body to be successful at monitoring the work of its members there would need to be a robust auditing process.  Stephen Kenwright, SEO speaker and trainer suggested, “The most obvious way for a regulator to work in this industry is to turn Google’s webmaster guidelines into a checklist and audit an agency’s accounts like Ofsted in schools.”

Twitter message from Stephen Kenwright suggesting regulation through a Google-inspired checklist

Twitter message from Stephen Kenwright suggesting regulation through a Google-inspired checklist

This would ensure that members are adhering to the guidelines that Google sets out for inclusion in its search engine and could help protect clients from suffering manual actions as a result of poor SEO practice.

External auditing checklists may need to be extended past Google’s guidelines. In order to ensure SEOs’ optimizing for other search engines are still monitored but not hampered in their efforts, the list would need to be more generic. There is also the question of how “grey hat” SEO would be treated under this system.

There might also be client privacy issues and the associated paperwork could be too time-consuming for sole-practitioners to bare. Fees would likely need to be charged which could be cost prohibitive for newer agencies or contractors.

Code of practice

Perhaps the answer isn’t in a series of rigid rules, but a code of practice that the practitioner signs up to?  As SEO Consultant Ric Rodriguez suggested, “regulating the industry is going to be really difficult. To start with, we’d need to establish a baseline code of practice, which given the subjectivity of the channel, is difficult in its own right”. This is a fair point, how does a code of practice get universally accepted in an industry that does not have an agreed upon standard of “good practice”? As Ric suggests, “given SEO is unpredictable, it’s hard to regulate mis-selling around results because no one can predict them”, so perhaps the code should center around tempering the promises made to prospective clients, to prevent unrealistic expectations following impossible claims.

Education

Suggestions have been made that the onus shouldn’t be on the SEO industry to regulate itself but on educating clients to make more informed decisions.  Rodriguez proposed, “what I think could work is an established body, that puts out information on “good advice”, offers a support function, that’s impartial […] it’s not regulation, but it may help filter out bad selling practices”

Through the formation of a trusted body that provides support and advice, businesses with little understanding of SEO good practice might feel more confident in what to look for in SEO support. They would have access to impartial experts who could provide advice on whether an agency seems trustworthy.

Ethics clauses

Another argument is that the risk is so great that SEO consultants should make a point of formalizing their commitment to their clients’ successes in their contracts. This would give clients legal recourse if they felt their agency had not met their agreement, however they would only be as enforceable as local laws allowed and it would be natural for agencies or individuals engaging in shady practices to opt-out of including these clauses or make them so loose they wouldn’t really protect the client from much.

Certification

If the industry and self-regulation are too hard to achieve then perhaps the answer lies in increasing the knowledge and expertise of SEOs and recognizing this through qualifications. Many tool providers and agencies offer SEO training programs of varying subject matter and complexity, often accompanied by a certificate. These go some way to reassuring clients that their prospective SEO partner knows a thing or two about the industry but they don ‘t necessarily guarantee that the knowledge gained through the course could be put into action effectively on their or others’ campaigns.

The other issue with training courses and certification is the qualifications are only good at certifying the knowledge gained at that moment in time. With the way digital marketing and SEO progress, it would be hard to prevent a certification from becoming outdated quickly.

Continuing professional development

Perhaps then, if the certification process isn’t sufficient due to the ever-changing nature of SEO, we need to look at continuing professional development. Institutes like the Chartered Institute of Marketing (CIM) in the UK marries both the certification and ongoing development process well. Members of the Institute become “chartered” after displaying sufficient knowledge of marketing either through the CIM qualifications or work experience. Once they are chartered they need to undergo a certain number of hours to continue professional development each year in order to remain chartered. A similar system for the SEO industry would ensure that practitioners are kept current on developments through attendance at conferences, training courses, and meetups.

Conclusion

It’s important to ensure that clients and in-house teams are confident that the SEO they get support from knows what they are doing. How this is achieved is a more complex issue. As with SEO itself, there isn’t a cut and dry solution. One thing is clear however, for the quality of SEO provision to improve education is key – both for practitioners and the businesses who hire them.

Helen Pollitt is the Head of SEO Avenue Digital. She can be found on Twitter .

Share your views, opinions, and suggestions in the comments.

Related reading

Image optimization for SEO Everything you need to know for success

A guide to implementing Google’s “How-to” schema

Goodbye to average position on Google SERPs

The middle ground for single keyword ad groups (SKAGs)

How to combat marketing’s greatest enemy: Time

In recent days I’ve started thinking about our second half of 2019 plan and came across an old file, a 2018 planning deck. I looked through a few slides, remembering how much time my team had put into getting campaigns aligned, our calendar precisely mapped out, and priorities outlined.

We barely followed any of it. As the boxer Mike Tyson once said, “Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face.”

Though we’re not in a boxing ring, the sentiment applies to marketing: needs and priorities change in the blink of an eye, other trends emerge and pull you in different directions, new executives shakeup the vision for your business strategy. And none of that you can truly plan for.

Marketers like planning because it gives us a sense of control, organization and vision for how things will rollout. While we go to painstaking lengths to create these plans that detail our actions, though, the market is evolving. By the time you’ve conceived the perfect plan, it’s no longer what the market needs anymore.

Time is the magical, but a forgotten ingredient in many marketing initiatives. But our antiquated “planning” mindset hinders us in today’s always-on world. Instead, you need to foster a scrappy mindset amongst your team. At its heart, marketing at its heart is about putting out a message. Scrappy marketing is about doing that quickly and resourcefully. Don’t worry about getting things perfect,; worry about getting things done.

Here’s how you can maximize your team’s time, get scrappy and get ahead of your competitors.

Become a trusted, go-to resource

All of us have websites we visit every day and trust. These have usually been news organizations, but more than ever there are brand voices that provide valuable content and insights. From CMO.com by Adobe or Woolly Magazine by Casper, more consumers are looking to brands for their expertise and opinions.

Developing your brand into a trusted news source is therefore a double-edged sword: readers are more receptive to taking your content seriously and engaging with it. But there’s more competition and noise than before. It’s critical that you carve out a strong voice and identify the areas where you truly want to be a thought leader. It’s best to start with a narrow focus and gain credibility for your expertise than to go broad initially and not be taken seriously. You can always expand the number of topics you discuss.

Many of us trust or don’t trust certain news sources in our personal lives; and that mindset is starting to bleed into our professional lives, too, as more people view brands as news producers themselves. You want your audience to trust and rely on your company’s insights.

Distinguish from competitors by being always on

The news cycle is 24 hours a day, and can change in the time it takes to publish a single Tweet. If your marketing is not always on as well, you’re already behind. You need to have a relentless, steady stream of content that’s ready for your audience whenever they are.

How so? Have a proactive, not reactive marketing strategy. Develop avenues to get real-time feedback from customers and prospects to understand what they’re most curious or concerned about, and adapt your marketing accordingly. This feedback will help you discover where there’s white space in your industry, and what you should focus on when it comes to content creation.

Then develop the channels to get that content out – like a webinar series with weekly insights. Conductor’s 30 | 30 webinar, which recaps the last 30 days in search, social and content, is a good example. So is App Annie’s weekly Mobile Minute blogs, which provides insights into how mobile is impacting current events and consumer trends.

Whatever your channel, don’t let perfect get in the way of good. If there’s a news cycle that’s breaking and set to impact your market, do a quick video or webinar explaining what it means for your audience and what they should be watching for in the days to come. Send out an email with a couple paragraphs explaining the latest trend in simple, digestible bits of content. Re-use that email copy for blog and social posts. Share a quote from your CEO with relevant journalists who can copy and paste it into articles they are working on about this breaking story. Creating a strong voice is half the battle, but beating your competitors to the punch is also vital.

Structuring your team for success

You can’t plan for the unexpected, but you can create a flexible team. As a marketing leader, think about how your team is structured: are channels from demand gen to brand to public relations siloed? In reality, what aspects of marketing aren’t related to demand gen, brand, and your public relations? They’re all interwoven and when you’re siloed by channel, that’s the opposite of agile marketing.

Agile marketing is about an integrated scrum mindset, where all can collaborate and move things forward, together. Marketing shouldn’t be an assembly line, with team members waiting on others to finish their job to keep the ball rolling. That’s why siloed teams create execution gaps. So if you’re struggling to get your team all pulling in the same direction, you should revamp your team’s organization to be agile and react in real-time. Just remember that any moment spent waiting to publish is a moment where a prospect could be consuming your content. Through an always-on approach, scrappy, agile marketing allows you to build both visibility and engagement as your prospects enter the buying journey.

As you gear up for your second half plans for 2019, know that you’ll have to always create a general outline of priorities and initiatives. But ensure that everyone understands how much these priorities will (and should) change. If you are doing quality marketing and if you truly value your prospect’s time, then your marketing will actually be aligned with the times — and not with any rigid, outdated plan.


Opinions expressed in this article are those of the guest author and not necessarily Marketing Land. Staff authors are listed here.


About The Author

Joe Hyland is the CMO of the leading webinar platform company, ON24, where he is responsible for the company’s global marketing, communication and brand strategy. He has over a decade of experience creating and marketing innovative products in the enterprise and SaaS software markets. Before joining ON24, Hyland was the CMO at Taulia, the SaaS market-leading financial supply chain company. He holds a Bachelor’s degree from Dartmouth College.

Exclusive interview with Craig Campbell: Golden nuggets every SEO needs to know

Note: This is not a sponsored post.

Craig Campbell is a well-known SEO expert from Glasgow, UK. He has 17 years of experience in SEO Consulting and Digital Marketing. Craig owns an agency where he manages a small team so that he can deliver better results to his loyal clientele. He is also a regular SEMrush webinar host, SEO trainer, and speaker. Since Craig has been helping over a hundred businesses, he decided to start flipping websites for profit.

In this interview, Craig shared his ups and downs of his experience wearing different hats. He also offers actionable tips SEOs can utilize for their own business venture. His style is also very unique, as he is a straightforward guy who cuts straight through the noise – which is exactly why he has been invited to speak at several conferences all over the world, including Thailand, London, Paris, Italy, and more. He is very active on Social Media and has a large following on Twitter @craigcampbell03, where he oftentimes shares a lot of his mind-blowing tips.

Craig Campbell at a conferenceSource: Chang Mai Conference 2018

Karina Tama: You have a lot of experience in Digital Marketing from owning an agency, being a conference speaker, webinar speaker, contributor, selling online courses, flipping websites for profit, and selling online. Which of these methods generates the most income? Which was the fastest to build?

Craig Campbell: From my own personal experience, the online courses and flipping websites are the most profitable and also the quickest to scale. Having an agency involves a lot of costs attached to the staff, office space, etc, and more time spent with clients as well which is always going to be harder to scale. But the great thing about this industry is that you can make money in a number of different ways, whether that is an affiliate, selling courses, digital agency owner or being a freelancer. Plus, you can niche it down even further by becoming the guy who catches expired domains, the site audit specialist or whatever.

What I highlighted is that I’ve made a lot of mistakes prior to getting myself into the position I’m in now, but this model suits me as a person, how I work, my personality and temperament.

The key is to do what you enjoy doing and model your business around that.

KT: Can you share your experience flipping websites for profit and how much money a person can make?

The answer to this is difficult because you can buy a website for 1 million dollars, and flip it for 2 or 3 times the price by doing some work on the site; however, not many people have that type of money to invest in projects.

But to give you an example, I bought a website for £10,000 and spend around 4k on the site getting some content and links done, and flipped the website for 48k within a 4 month period. There are folks out there doing a lot more than that.  Have a look at empireflippers.com to see what some of the websites on there are selling for.

These sites have to produce proof of analytics and revenue too, so it’s not pie in the sky stuff if you get in and do the right kind of work.

Bill Slawski's tweet about Craig Campbell's website flipping skillsSource: Twitter

KT: You always said you’ve made massive mistakes over your years. Can you highlight the biggest and most costly ones?

CC: The mistakes I’ve made do vary and may not be something I would automatically discard for other folks. But I spent a lot of time and effort into building an agency, building up staff and using up a lot of time and energy into doing so. I would have been better spending my time working more efficiently in working on affiliate marketing websites at a much earlier stage. So that is one that I personally feel was a mistake.

But to be honest I’ve made more mistakes than most. I’m an impulsive guy and jumped head first into setting up businesses without doing research first. Years ago I set up a vaping ecommerce store and there was tons of search for the products. I had confidence in my ability to rank and make it work.

What I didn’t do was proper research into the legal side of things. Paid ads weren’t allowed, and taking payments via any source other than PayPal wasn’t allowed. There were so many other little legal niggles on top of having unreliable drop shippers and products, and brands that were constantly changing which resulted in me having a project that I put a lot of time and money into. I got little to no return, simply because I didn’t do any real research.

So do research on all aspects of the business, not just the keyword volumes as that is something I’ve done a number of times and it ended up in failed ventures and lost money.

 KT: What’s the minimum commission percentage someone needs to make in order to be able to fund their affiliate marketing business?

CC: This is real difficult to answer as Amazon pays on average five percent but if you get sheer volume, you can still afford to get the content, website maintenance, and everything else done properly. But on a personal level, I do feel Amazon affiliates are hard to get off the ground realistically on a low budget because the commissions are so low. Unless you have a budget to spend to get it off the ground, it is difficult to get going.

I’ve got a golf site and it cost me around 15k to get the site up to a level where it pulls in 1k per month. So it’s going to take me 15 months via Amazon affiliates to get my money back, providing they don’t cut the commission again, and providing Googles updates don’t impact my site. It’s not a cost-effective option choosing low commissions, and as a result, I have to look to private affiliate options to better monetize my golf site to make sure that I’m not constantly losing money on that particular project.

KT: Based on your experience, what is the minimum budget a person needs to start an online business?

CC: In general, I think you need to be realistic and you are likely to need around 10 to 20k to get a good start in the online business world. Of course, there are going to be instances where it can be done for a lot less in weak niches.

 KT: What are the most common client misconceptions about SEO? What’s the best way to deal with them as an agency owner?

CC: This is hard. I have always personally found clients hard to deal with, but I completely get their point at times as so many clients have been given the run around by agencies out there offering a poor service. I think client education is important. If you have an agency, by all means, you don’t give them the whole strategy. But they need to understand that SEO isn’t a quick solution and it can’t be done for a few hundred bucks per month. There is time, effort, and expertise alongside the costs for links, content, staff, offices and business profits to be made, so you do get what you pay for.

There are the clients who don’t mind spending money, but want to know way too much about SEO and spend more time on emails and calls talking about SEO than you do getting work done. In this instance, we tell clients we can offer them training and consultancy at an additional cost.

I do feel in our industry we get questions from clients like: where are you getting your links from?, What on page tweaks are you doing? The clients are basically digging deep into how the work is being done, and that will only result in them being fed a load of sales talk or misleads.

So in my opinion with SEO if you deal with clients, give them traffic rankings and improvements along the way. But keep them at arm’s length so that they don’t need to know the in’s and outs of the strategy. I do feel many people think that they can simply expect an agency to hand the secret sauce over on a plate with no questions asked. No other business in the world would do that, so why expect it from SEOs?

So set expectation levels from the get-go and make sure they know how and what you will be reporting on. The minute you let the client walk all over you, you are in big trouble.

KT: For a person that is just starting a small SEO agency and has a limited budget, what are the must-have SEO tools to get the job done?

CC: SEMrush is a good all in one SEO tool. You do have other low costs tools like contentcal.io which is a social media scheduling tool that I like. It helps me schedule and set up all my social media messages and it is very low cost.

Then as you grow you can look into other tools that will help you grow, but these are just two to begin with. Most agencies have five or six different tools if not more that will help them with their day to day work and processes.

KT: What time management tips do you have for someone starting an agency? How do you prevent burnout?

CC: Well, what I can say is in the past when I started out, I worked so hard I ended up with anxiety and depression at one point, working 18-hour shifts if not more, unsociable hours and having no real structure was tough.

Then I was young, naive and thought I wouldn’t ever break, but there comes a time when you do burn out and don’t become productive.

In the end, I removed emails from my phone. I worked 9-5 Monday to Friday, and I got away from the laptop in the evening and choose to spend time doing things I enjoy to relax with my family and friends. Also, I spend my weekends switching off.

So rather than replying to client emails in the middle of the night from your mobile in bed, relax, sleep and get into the routine of working normal business hours.

I know many of us have to put a serious grind in at the start to build a business and it might take a little bit more than nine-to-five Monday to Friday to get the business off the ground. But do try and take time out, do try and wind down and de-stress and do spend time with your family and friends as you only live once, and you work to live, not live to work.

 KT: You always said it’s important to be at the top of your game. How do you do it and what’s your advice to others about it?

CC: Network regularly, and surround yourself with the right people.

I regularly speak at events and network with people but I am also learning at the same time. I also go to private masterminds which is useful as you can learn and share with some of the top names in the industry and that for me is what keeps you at the top of your game.

Obviously, these things cost time, money and effort to get along too. But you need to invest in yourself if you want to be the best you can be. In recent years, it’s also important to give something back as no-one is going to accept some leach into the circle. So offering value in yourself is massively important. The more you open up, the more others will open up.

I potentially in the past thought this would be crazy to open up to your peers. But when you realize there is money for us all to make and no-one really cares about your specific niche, you will find that you can learn more and develop.

I would say speaking at events has also helped me massively with that type of thing as well. As speaking gets me to the events, but the information shared when talking one on one with people, or very often at the bar before or after events is where the golden nuggets come from. You need to be there to get them, or someone else will.

KT: In your experience with ROI SEO such as paying for traffic, and buying backlinks, have you ever had a website penalized for this?

CC: Through testing, I have crashed and burned websites to see how far I could push them. But never had a money site penalized by SEO work that I have done. However, I have negative SEO attacks and stuff like that where I have had some issues. But the intention is never to get my websites banned. I try and do things as ethically as I can. Of course, I would be lying to say I didn’t bend a few rules here and there, but who doesn’t?

But if you want to simply go out and pay for spammy links, it’s a sure way to ruin your business, mix things up, try and do as much as you can ethically. Then look at the other stuff as the icing on the cake is maybe the best way to look at things.

One thing I would say is, don’t believe all the scaremongering there is out there. Links still work well, keep them relevant, with sites with good DR and from websites that get traffic and you won’t go far wrong.

Avoid getting links from low-quality sites with no traffic, link farms and all of that stuff, work smart and know what your buying and you will be fine.

KT: You have been to conferences in so many countries. Do you have plans to do any conferences in the USA? 

CC: I’d love to do some in the USA. I’m fairly well known in the UK and Europe from speaking at events.

I would love to do if the opportunity came up. I have been to Thailand, India, Vietnam, Israel and a few others lined up this year. So I’m definitely up for traveling and speaking wherever I can.

I had the pleasure to get to know Craig much more during this interview and I can definitely say he is an authentic and well-rounded person. He has a good sense of humor and loves to collaborate. I am sure we will have Craig soon speaking in the USA.

Note: This interview has been condensed for publishing purposes.

Karina Tama is a contributor for Forbes, Thrive Global and the El Distrito Newspaper. She can be found on Twitter .

Google to buy unified data platform Looker for $2.6 billion to strengthen Cloud analytics

Earlier today, Google announced plans to acquire unified data and analytics platform Looker for $2.6 billion in an all-cash transaction. Once the deal is complete later this year, Looker will join Google Cloud.

“Google Cloud is being used by many of the leading organizations in the world for analytics and decision-making. The combination of Google Cloud and Looker will enable customers to harness data in new ways to drive their digital transformation,” said Thomas Kurian, chief executive officer of Google Cloud. “We remain committed to our multi-cloud strategy and will retain and expand Looker’s capabilities to analyze data across Clouds.”

Why we should care

As martech investments continue to grow and digital transformation catches on, the need for data and analytics is highlighted more than ever. However, one of the biggest analytics challenges digital marketers face continues to be the underlying martech infrastructure and pulling the different pieces together to create meaningful, actionable insights.

“The data analytics market is growing incredibly fast as companies look to leverage all of their data to make more informed decisions,” said Frank Gens, Senior Vice President & Chief Analyst, IDC. “Google Cloud is one of the leaders in the data warehouse market, and the addition of Looker will further strengthen their ability to serve the needs of enterprise customers while also advancing their commitment to multi-cloud.”

The addition of Looker to the Google Cloud ecosystem could afford users the ability to strengthen their analytics, which in turn should lead to better decision-making and improve digital execution.

More on the news

  • Looker is a unified data platform that integrates data into the daily workflow of users and enables organizations to extract value from the data.
  • The acquisition builds on an existing partnership between the two companies where they share more than 350 joint customers, including Buzzfeed, Hearst, King, Sunrun, WPP Essence and Yahoo!.

About The Author

Jennifer Videtta Cannon serves as Third Door Media’s Senior Editor, covering topics from email marketing and analytics to CRM and project management. With over a decade of organizational digital marketing experience, she has overseen digital marketing operations for NHL franchises and held roles at tech companies including Salesforce, advising enterprise marketers on maximizing their martech capabilities. Jennifer formerly organized the Inbound Marketing Summit and holds a certificate in Digital Marketing Analytics from MIT Sloan School of Management.